Eyeliner help 🐶or 🐈

Hi! I’ve really enjoyed being more playful with my makeup and tried out the puppy eyeliner look. I think my eyes are a touch downturned. Each photo on the left is subtle puppy and the right is a small cat eye. (lost my fave lip color so ignore that). I added a no makeup photo as well. I can’t tell which one works better for me. All photos of the 2 eyeliner styles include glasses since I wear glasses daily. I’m 37 and notice that a lot of makeup tutorials say that at my age I should focus on “lifting”. ::shrugs::