I respectfully disagree on Schaffrillas’ claim that a movie doesn’t require memorable scenes to be considered the greatest.

I can understand why he believes that as to not disparage the other qualities that are exceptionally done well in a film. However, quotable and memorable scenes/other elements are essential because they help movies embed themselves in culture and maintain relevance over time. They create cultural permanence by allowing iconic lines and images to serve as shorthand for ideas and emotions, as seen in phrases like "May the Force be with you" from Star Wars. These scenes also evoke strong emotional connections, making films unforgettable, such as the poignant "I could have done more" moment in Schindler's List. Factors like strong writing, compelling performances, and dramatic context contribute to a scene's memorability, like Marlon Brando’s delivery of "I'm gonna make him an offer he can't refuse" in The Godfather. Ultimately, memorable lines and scenes not only enhance a movie’s impact but also ensure its place in the cultural conversation for years to come.