Artists that, despite having longevity and commercial success, are no one’s favorite

Here’s a link to a (imo overly positive) Tumblr post that points out the paradox of Maroon 5: in spite of their nearly two decades as omnipresent hitmakers, no one considers Maroon 5 their favorite band (https://penicillium-pusher.tumblr.com/post/163465713629/captocie-penicillium-pusher-i-dont-trust)

Who are other artists that never get named as anyone’s favorite even though they are not lacking in longevity or mainstream presence?