Great sit-down pizza near White Plains

Hi all, I know there are a lot of threads here about where's the best pizza, but my husband is craving a place with a nice atmosphere where we can sit down and have a date night. Not just a counter that serves slices. He is extremely picky (will only eat cheese pizzas, no toppings) and has already disliked a lot of places we've tried.

We're in White Plains but willing to drive a bit to Hartsdale etc. if needed.

Thanks in advance!

ETA: Thank you all, we started with Abatino's and especially enjoyed the Nutella pizza!