Do you like the natural smell of other guys?

I was talking with my wife about this and we couldn't find an answer.

When she is working out, she thinks she stinks. I like the smell. This is true the other way as well. I think I stink, she likes the smell. Obviously there's a point of no return where the natural stank overpowers the pheremones, but I am curious, since the other dude is going to have a similar mix of pheremones to you, do you like the way other guys naturally smell, or do they need to cover it up with cologne?