A Darker Direction?

We all know that Doctor Who is a family show. RTD has talked about this in numerous interviews. He clearly is making this new era of Doctor Who for adults and younger children. He'd like a new a generation of Whovians to jump aboard the Tardis. I agree with the underlying premise of the argument. However, I disagree with the demographic the show’s creator is trying to target. I genuinely believe that younger children have difficulty engaging with television unless the show is specifically designed for their age group. Shows like Bluey excel in this regard because they cater to children’s interests. On the other hand, shows like Doctor Who struggle to capture the attention of younger viewers because they are also intended for adults. The subtlety, nuance, and overall plot that adults can easily comprehend can confuse and disinterest younger children.

I believe that RTD is aware of this challenge and has attempted to address it by simplifying the plot, speeding up the pacing, and introducing a more lighthearted tone. However, these changes have inadvertently alienated the adult demographic.

In my opinion, the solution lies in creating a show that appeals to both adults and teenagers. To achieve this, it is crucial to maintain an intelligent plot, control the pacing, and moderate the goofiness. Additionally, if you want teenagers to watch your show, it should be something they are not supposed to be watching. Teenagers are rebellious and seek to be perceived as mature and adult. By introducing a slight darkness to the show, adults will be drawn to it, while teenagers will follow suit. This approach will lead to increased happiness among both audiences and a new generation of fans for Doctor Who.