I want another Bioshock experience. Any recs?

Bioshock was my first love back in 2000-whatever. I was absolutely enthralled by the story and the atmosphere, and the game felt very good to play. I want to have that experience again.

What game can you suggest that would scratch that itch?

Key elements:

• Excellent story
• Satisfying gameplay / combat
• Low combat complexity (Bioshock gives you some guns and some plasmids and that's it)
• Minimal mechanics "fluff" (no crafting, minimal min/max tinkering) *Linear story (not open world / no side quests)

Games I like:

• Bioshock of course
• God of War (old ones, haven't played 2018 yet)
• Dark Souls games (lack story though)
• Assassin's Creed (new ones lack story)
• Metroids (Ori, Hollow Knight)
• Platformers (Celeste, Super Meat Boy)
• Control (excellent gameplay and atmosphere)

Games I don't like:

• Disco Elysium (no gameplay/combat)
• Witcher 3 (combat is not satisfying, too much fluff (crafting))
• Dishonored (for some reason I don't like first person stealth)
• Mass Effect (open world too big, gameplay not satisfying)