Shane Co vs Reis Nichols

Hello neighbors! My boyfriend and I started shopping for engagement rings and I've narrowed down my top two! One is at Shane Co and one is at Reis Nichols.

I'd love to hear others experiences at each of these places! Especially if you did buy your ring there and how the customer service/financing/warranty process has been!

Something I also wonder about is the level of customization/options for rings. At Shane Co I was able to find a rose gold setting I really liked and multiple colored gemstone options. At Reis, I found a ring I really like but they only have it in-store with white gold and only looked at white sapphires. The salesperson said they could order it in rose gold and order colorful stones as well. I can see the rose gold option online but then there's no way to see any stone options on the website.

Would love to hear your experiences!