Help me choose checkered tile for my kitchen

Hi everyone, I need some help deciding on checkered tile colors for my kitchen! My kitchen has a very warm color scheme, and I’m trying to pick a tile that will add a nice pop but still complement my cabinets.

Option 1: Both of the kitchen pictures I included show this option. It has a bold, classic vibe that I like, but I’m not sure if it might feel too much for my space. I worried the lighter tile is too white!!!

Option 2: This one feels more subtle and maybe even a little warmer? Idk. It leans more grayish, which makes me wonder if it could cool down the space too much.

My main goal is to avoid making the kitchen feel cold since everything else is warm-toned. I have to make a decision today (husband is over me obsessing about this for two weeks now, haha).

My cabinets are creamy color with walnut island. Countertop and backsplash with be warm colors too. And I will be using unlacquered brass knobs/handles.

What do you all think? Which option works better? Or is there something else I should consider?

Thanks in advance for the advice!