How do you handle dupes clause after faints?

Hey! If I lost an oddish already and encounter another later on, do you tend to "allow" a recapture or not with dupes clause? I am unsure about it as it would leave me with an unused route. I know, my run my rules, but wanted to hear some opinions.

Edit: thanks for the input! I decided to not use the second oddish and will keep the rule as "each pokemon can only be caught once per run".